Health care summit didn’t accomplish anything
Few if any thought the meeting would result in agreement on a bipartisan bill that would breeze through the halls of Congress. The Republicans wanted any legislation to start from scratch and be built in a true bipartisan fashion.
The Democrats rejected that approach and said the bills enacted by the Democratic majorities in the House and Senate had to serve as the benchmark for any legislation.
If everyone knew the “summit” wasn’t going to accomplish anything, why was it held?
From the standpoint of the Republicans, not showing up wasn’t an option. Had they refused the president’s invitation to attend, they would have been lambasted for closing the door in advance on any possibility of a bipartisan approach to health care reform.
The Democrats certainly had nothing to lose by attending the summit. The bill enacted by the House had barely enough votes to succeed in the heavily Democratic chamber. The Senate bill was enacted with exactly the 60 votes needed to cut off the filibuster-with every Democrat voting for it and every Republican voting against it.
That was, of course, before the Republican Scott Brown won the open Democratic Senate Seat in Massachusetts that became vacant when Ted Kennedy passed away. Brown won that seat by campaigning to be the 41st vote to stop the health care legislation.
The president had the most to gain from the “summit.” In the give-and-take with the GOP at its conference in Baltimore earlier this year, Team Obama felt the president hit a home run. His poll numbers improved for a short period of time because, his advisors believed, his “bipartisan” credentials had been burnished. The West Wing crowd developed a strategy to move the stalled health care legislation forward using the “summit” as a starting point.
The strategy called for using the marathon photo op to give the president’s sagging popularity another bump in the polls and to put an “obstructionist” face on the Republicans. The targets for the White House game plan are the wavering Democrats whose votes are needed to ram through the legislation by using the “reconciliation” process that would bypass the filibuster that the Republicans can now successfully employ with their 41 votes.
It is obvious that President Obama and the Democrats will now say “we tried!” and move on to the controversial reconciliation approach that will create an even larger firestorm in the halls of Congress. But that will come with a price. Polling data shows the public does not support the expansive (and expensive) bills being pushed by the Democratic majorities.
Polling also shows that jobs and the economy-not health care-are the issues the public wants addressed. Many voters who have worries about the economy are perplexed over the amount of time and energy devoted to health care while unemployment continues to grow.
The White House strategy to use the reconciliation process contains much uncertainty, but there is one thing certain about the approach: it will keep the high-profile health care debate going for months. If the public is tired of the focus on the health care issue now and progressively less supportive of the effort as time goes by, how is that a plus for the Democrats? The president’s team seems to think that doubling down their bets on health care will eventually bring them a win. Perhaps so. But it could just as easily turn off the voters so badly that they foreclose on the Democratic majorities in the House and Senate and make President Obama a lame duck less than two years into his presidency.
Subscribe Today and Save!!!
St. Charles Herald-Guide is an award-winning newspaper that covers all aspects of St. Charles Parish - from schools and parish government news to social events, features on our local residents and sports.
Order your subscription today!
Hahnville head football coach Lou Valdin has resigned after 15 years with the...
In order to track down vandals who have used pellet guns to cause damage to 11...
Over the past few years, the food truck industry has become an increasing culinary...
Playoff quarterfinals players of the week for the 2013 high school football season. ...
The St. Charles Parish Sheriff’s Office is asking for help identifying a man who...
A bicyclist was killed after getting hit by a car at the intersection of Barton...
The Fitness Club of Boutte offers superior service. The club provides the support and tools you need to reach your goals. Come in and get fit!
Des Allemands man charged with home arson - 1642 views
A 43-year-old Des Allemands man was arrested and charged with an arson that destroyed a shed and caused extensive damage to a home on Matherne Drive last May.