Opposition to health care reform not coming from ‘naysayers’
They are concerned about the cost, the impact on the exploding national debt, and yet another government intrusion into the private marketplace. Seemingly oblivious to that fact, President Obama and congressional leaders claim that the opposition to their health care legislation is coming from “naysayers” who only want the status quo and have no proposals of their own.
To the contrary, numerous health care reform proposals that differ from the president’s have been introduced. Amendments that would change the legislation offered by the Democratic majority have been offered, but none of them stand a chance to go anywhere because the ruling coalition in Congress will not let them advance.
Here is a look at some reforms that have been offered by the so-called “naysayers” but are opposed by the congressional leadership.
How about tort reform? A considerable amount of the increased cost in health care comes from the practice of defensive medicine-ordering potentially unnecessary tests and procedures to protect against malpractice suits filed by patients and their attorneys. The proposals offered by the Democratic majority have not one iota of malpractice reform in them. Why? Because the segment of the legal community that contributes heavily to Democratic candidates will not tolerate it. If the legislation being offered by the Democrats becomes law, doctors and hospitals will continue to pay heavily for malpractice insurance and continue to practice defensive medicine. The cost involved will continue to be passed on to patients and their insurers.
Tax credits for individual medical insurance policyholders is another beneficial policy that is absent in the ObamaCare proposals. Instead of attempting to tax employer-provided health insurance for employees, the “geniuses” in Washington should be extending the tax credits to workers who do not have employer-provided health insurance. That would level the playing field and lower the number of uninsured individuals.
The president and the congressional leadership seem hell-bent on establishing a “public option” of insurance provided by the federal government. They say it is necessary to “compete” with private insurance companies and “keep them honest.” The public opinion polls, however, show the voters are not at all interested in having the federal government get into the health insurance business. There are thousands of private health insurance companies in America. If Obama and the Democratic leadership want to generate more competition, they can abolish the prohibition against insurance companies not being able to sell policies across state lines. The folks in power in Washington don't support that because what they are really interested in is government-run health care, not more competition.
The first thing any health care reform legislation should do is root out the huge amount of fraud currently afflicting Medicare and Medicaid. Tens of billions of dollars annually are being ripped off by means of overutilization and bogus charges for procedures never done. How can anyone support a further expansion of government-run health insurance when the federal government can’t adequately police the large portion of the health care system it is currently running?
Opponents of the health care legislation put forth by President Obama and his allies have legitimate reasons for fighting it. Many of them have also proposed alternatives that are less expensive, won't add more layers to the exploding federal debt, and will crack down on lawsuit abuse and fraud. Certainly their proposals are fair game for scrutiny. But they shouldn’t be dismissed as simply the mutterings of “naysayers.”
Subscribe Today and Save!!!
St. Charles Herald-Guide is an award-winning newspaper that covers all aspects of St. Charles Parish - from schools and parish government news to social events, features on our local residents and sports.
Order your subscription today!
It had been a long 18-hour day observing a presidential election in the Republic of...
A St. Rose man has received a mandatory sentence of life in prison for the 2012...
After finishing last season 14-1 and losing a host of key players to graduation,...
Ashlyn Frahm is this year’s salutatorian for Destrehan High School (DHS)....
HBO is back in St. Charles Parish filming an eight-part series called “Quarry” that...
A St. Rose woman has been arrested in connection with the alleged hit-and-run death...
When you visit Dr. Joshua C. Patella and his team at Patella Dental, you are our top priority. Our entire general dentistry team is dedicated to providing you with the personalized, gentle care that you deserve. We believe that teeth should look and feel
St. Charles Parish splash park will open full-time in June - 1348 views
Opened last year, St. Charles Parish’s Ormond Spray Park appears to be a splashing success.