Beware the ides of May
Governor Jindal captured the early focus of the session with his short-lived plan to repeal the personal income tax primarily by replacing it with a half-billion-dollar net increase in business taxes. That plan’s demise cleared the decks for the budget debate. While pushing his tax swap plan, the governor made it clear that he would veto any approach that was not revenue neutral when it came to addressing changes in the tax structure. He reaffirmed that posture regarding any revenue measures coming to his desk related to the budget debate.
The budget proposal enacted by the House clearly is not revenue neutral regarding tax increases. The House proposal also ties numerous budget reforms to the revenue and the appropriations bills in an attempt to say that everything fails if the package as a whole is not adopted. It is questionable whether either the Senate or the governor will concur in that approach.
Some good news on the budget front came on May 15 when the Revenue Estimating Conference (REC) certified $155 million in enhanced revenue for the budget now being confected. The REC also certified approximately $130 million in additional revenue available in the current budget. Some of that money may end up assisting with the budget currently under construction through various legislative and bookkeeping maneuvers that have been employed in the past.
The House version of the budget used $200 million in proposed tax amnesty revenues to replace much of the one-time money that Governor Jindal placed in his executive budget. The amnesty legislation has not made it through the legislative process and quite possibly would not be recognized by the REC as recurring revenue to pay for recurring expenditures if it is enacted.
The play now goes to the Senate. The key players there must deal with the House budget with its internal booby traps (don’t expect the Senate to take those seriously) and the governor’s vow to veto any tax increase bills that aren’t offset by tax reductions. The Senate generally tries to play team ball with governors, so expect the body to try to confect some version of a scaled-down tax swap that would allow the governor to claim success in some fashion for his original goal of the session. The House budget also contains more than $100 million in somewhat vague cuts. Senators will have to decide if they will maintain those cuts, eliminate them, or develop a different cut menu.
What the Senate is adept at doing is digging into the secret money closet and finding untapped revenue from various sources to close gaps in the budget. One likely scenario would be that the Senate adopts a tax swap to please the governor; keeps some of the House cuts but rearranges them; plugs the remaining holes with supplemental funds from sources that don’t require REC certification; and removes or ignores the requirement that everything in the House package must remain in place or else it all fails.
Then at some point late in the session, the Senate will send the revised proposal back to the House, which may not be enamored with the changes--particularly among the "Fiscal Hawks" who voted for tax increases in order to get the budget reforms they tried to make mandatory. At that point, the Democrats the Hawks aligned with originally would likely accept the Senate version of the budget and join with enough Republicans to pass it.
The governor would be happy under that scenario; the Senate would exercise its customary control over the budget; the House Democrats would go home content; and the Fiscal Hawks would be on the outside looking in.
Subscribe Today and Save!!!
St. Charles Herald-Guide is an award-winning newspaper that covers all aspects of St. Charles Parish - from schools and parish government news to social events, features on our local residents and sports.
Order your subscription today!
On Feb. 6, John Fowler’s life changed drastically.
Since being rescued from the swamp where she was thrown from Interstate 310 last...
For the second straight meeting between the two teams, Destrehan scored over 60...
With people pouring into United Way of St. Charles’ 14th annual Battle for the...
When the Winn-Dixie shopping spree that Paul Triche of Hahnville had won was over,...
Hahnville needed a victory in the worst way coming into its Friday night district...
Bent's RV is a Full Service RV Dealership in Louisiana.
Brother turned in Norco fugitives - 2365 views
Kaleb Perilloux was en route to pick up his brother and a friend in Prairieville last Thursday when he learned the two were fugitives wanted by the St. Charles Parish Sheriff’s Office.