Status quo defenders challenge education reforms
Act 2 expanded school choice through scholarships to participating nonpublic (or public) schools as well as individual course providers which could be private, nonpublic or public. Currently, about 4,900 children are on scholarships to 117 participating schools and, next week, the Board of Elementary and Secondary Education (BESE) will approve a list of new course providers.
The basis of this suit hinges on the constitutionality of using the state’s Minimum Foundation Formula (MFP) dollars to fund scholarships for low-income children who would have had to go to failing public schools. About one-third of Louisiana schools are rated as either "D" or "F" schools, and that’s using a very low-standard grading scale. The MFP is the mechanism by which state dollars are allocated to local school districts, and the MFP resolution included an allocation for state tax dollars to support the new school choice programs.
The other issue being decided is the processes used to approve the resolution containing the MFP during the session. Plaintiffs contest that the resolution had the force and effect of a legislative bill, which would have required 53 votes in the House of Representatives in order to pass. The resolution, SCR 99, received 51 House votes.
Defendants in the case, BESE and the State Department of Education, and intervenors Institute for Justice and the Black Alliance for Educational Options contend that use of tax dollars to fund education is a proper and constitutional use of MFP monies. At issue is the word "public" in the state constitution in regards to directing state tax dollars. Defendants argue nothing in the constitution limits how tax dollars can be used to support quality education. They further claim that the MFP resolution is not a legislative bill, as resolutions are not bound by most of the rules regarding bill introduction, passage, and approval or veto by the governor.
The Louisiana Association of Business and Industry (LABI) and other groups and citizens in the education reform movement supported Act 2 and the inclusion of school choice in the MFP. These groups believe that tax dollars should follow the child and should be used for the intended purposes of educating children. Indeed, the 43 school systems’ representatives in this lawsuit never uttered the word "student" and focus instead on their allegation that they are losing money to scholarships and providers outside of their school systems. Quality choices, opportunities for children, and intolerance of failed or failing schools just don’t seem to enter their equation. No matter the ruling, this case seems headed to the Louisiana Supreme Court and possibly ultimately the U.S. Supreme Court.
In another proceeding this week, a judge in federal court granted an injunction requested by the Tangipahoa Parish School Board to enjoin them from the provisions of Act 2. The board claimed that the 50 students in the scholarship program from their district make them unable to comply with the desegregation agreement in their 47-year old desegregation case. The judge granted the injunction, and included an additional injunction regarding Act 1 regarding teacher tenure and school board reforms. That case is being appealed to the U.S. Fifth Circuit.
The unions’ suit against Act 1 will be heard on December 17 in Baton Rouge. The defenders of the status quo will keep these bills tied up in court as long as possible. Unfortunately, if they are victorious, almost 5,000 children will have to return to schools that have failed them. However, that’s what happens when a child’s education is subservient to bureaucracies.
Subscribe Today and Save!!!
St. Charles Herald-Guide is an award-winning newspaper that covers all aspects of St. Charles Parish - from schools and parish government news to social events, features on our local residents and sports.
Order your subscription today!
After finishing last season 14-1 and losing a host of key players to graduation,...
A St. Rose man has received a mandatory sentence of life in prison for the 2012...
Ashlyn Frahm is this year’s salutatorian for Destrehan High School (DHS)....
Although Randall “Randy” Harvey had an idea he might be named Destrehan High School...
HBO is back in St. Charles Parish filming an eight-part series called “Quarry” that...
New York Life gives you the path to financial security of life time protection and value of life insurance, annuities, retirement plans and other financial planning. Let us help you achieve the financial goal of lifetime income!
Hahnville grad beats language barrier at HHS - 762 views
Imagine being 9 years old in a foreign country and attending school without knowing the language.